Kate Bloom and her stepbrother Codey Steele came to LA for their Amish rumspringa. During this time of experiences and experimentation, Kate and Codey fell in love. The revealing clothes of the Western world make it easy for them to experience each other's bodies in a way that they never could have in the Amish community. Kate and Codey's budding romance isn't without its setbacks. They are staying with Emma Starletto, a conservative Amish woman who has the worst timing imaginable.

Just as Kate has seduced Codey to come in for a kiss with a glimpse of her panties pushed up into her twat, Emma comes in and insists that Emma go put on more appropriate clothing. Later, and Codey are about to have some fun in the shower. Both are naked and Kate has her brother's dick in hand when Emma walks in and freaks out. Still later, Emma walks in on Kate giving Codey a blowjob while Codey squeezes Kate's ass. That's the final straw for Emma, who tells Kate that they need to leave. As Emma is trying to pull Kate away, Codey takes advantage of his stepsis's position on her hands and knees to slide it in doggy style.

Peeling off her clothes, Kate makes it clear that she's fully into getting it on with her bro. She gets him to sit down on the couch so she can climb into his lap and ride his fuck stick in her bare twat. Sliding his hands beneath Kate's ass, Codey helps se a sensual pace. Then he gets Kate on her back so he can piston in and out of her tight sheath and give it to her the way she craves. As Kate's cries fill the room, Codey gives in to her pleas and pulls out to cover her in jizz. The stepsiblings declare that they never want to be Amish again.